Hello dear
Welcome To Not Ray's Pizza
At Not Ray's Pizza, we celebrate the timeless charm of Brooklyn's pizza culture. Nestled on Fulton Street, our casual eatery offers a delightful array of Italian classics that prioritize quality and flavor. Our menu features everything from cheesy calzones to robust strombolis, each crafted with fresh ingredients. Patrons rave about our perfectly crispy crusts and the rich variety of vegetarian options. We pride ourselves on quick service and the friendly ambiance that invites families and groups alike. Whether you dine in, take out, or indulge in our catering, every bite at Not Ray's promises a taste of home that makes it more than just a pizza joint.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Square Pie Special
Stuffed Meat Pizza
Whole Wheat Vegetable Pizza
Bruschetta Pizza
About
Not Ray's Pizza
Welcome to the charming world of Not Ray's Pizza, a delightful pizzeria nestled in the heart of Brooklyn at 694 Fulton St, where every slice offers a taste of Italian culinary tradition. This beloved neighborhood gem stands out not just for its flavorful pies but for its commitment to creating a casual, welcoming atmosphere perfect for everyone, from families to late-night snack seekers.
Not Ray's Pizza embraces convenience with an array of services including delivery, takeout, and even catering, making it easy to satisfy your pizza cravings anytime. The QR code menus add a modern touch, allowing for seamless ordering. With both vegan and many vegetarian options available, there is something to please every palate. Customers rave about the crispy crusts and balanced flavors that aren't overly saucy or salty—elements that speak to the pizzeria’s dedication to quality.
The menu boasts an enticing selection of slices ranging from the classic Regular Slice at $3.75 to unique offerings like the Grandma Pesto Slice and comforting Lasagna Slice, each priced around $5.00. Regulars flock here for the Pepperoni Slice or the hearty Stuffed Meat Slice featuring pepperoni and ground beef, all guaranteed to satisfy any pizza lover's hunger.
What truly sets Not Ray's Pizza apart, though, is not just the food but the experience. Customers like Sara D. highlight the familial vibe, noting that the shop might be small, but the quality is big—a sentiment echoed by Gamali C., who cherishes the authentic Brooklyn ambiance and exceptional service. Regulars return not just for the pizzas, but to relive the nostalgia of their early days in the neighborhood, proving that this pizzeria is more than just a place to grab a bite; it’s a beloved community hub.
Whether you're enjoying a casual lunch, a hearty dinner with friends, or ordering in for a cozy night, Not Ray's Pizza promises a delightful experience filled with delicious flavors. With options for outdoor seating, wifi, and even TV for game nights, this spot is ideal for gathering with friends or making new ones.
In the hustle and bustle of Brooklyn, Not Ray's Pizza remains a beacon of comfort food that keeps its customers coming back for more, slice after slice. If you haven’t already, make it a mission to visit—your taste buds will thank you!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Had the pepperoni calzone. Must share with a friend. Very cheesy and such a small shop to eat at but worth it. Better than a food chain pizza. The pizza guys get you in and out!! ”
“ The food never disappoints! I grew up in the neighborhood but moved in 2004. To be able to return and the pizza is still great, wows me! Brought a friend with me and he co-signs this flavorful review. Service is excellent and it still has that good old Brooklyn pizza shop ambiance that I craved for. ”
“ Love my local pizza shop. All their flavors are delicious. The crust is nice and crispy, the pizza isn't over saucy or salty. I got a white pesto slice and a plain slice but added sausage. They have a pretty few tables to sit down on the inside and a tv. Service is always fast and friendly. ”
“ We ordered a bunch of pies from there. I am doing keto so opted for a chicken roll and just pulled the chicken from bread. There was not a lot of chicken on it. But tasted good. Everyone said pizza was good. Lots of choices ”
“ Good option for pizza. Plain cheese all day and everyday! Service is prompt and no frills. ”
“ Omg forgot about this place only cause I got a job across the street Pizza is amazing, will order here b when I'm feeling rich but it's worth it. ”
“ Descent spot for pizza. Has a nice toasty crust and cheesy. This is a good spot for Brooklyn style pizza. Reminds me of childhood and the service is friendly. $23 for half plain half pepperoni size large. The sausage pepperoni size large was about $29. Ambiance- fast pace with lots of people ordering. Very busy pizzeria and only a few seatings inside. Most people take their pizza to go and it's a really laid back spot to get pizza. ”
